Atornee
Get Started Free
Review My Settlement Agreement

Lawyer reviewed templates

employment settlement agreement review checklist uk

Settlement Agreement Review Checklist: What to Check Before You Sign

An employment settlement agreement review checklist for UK businesses is something most founders only wish they had before they signed. Settlement agreements end employment disputes cleanly — but they also waive significant legal rights, often permanently. Miss a clause, accept a vague reference provision, or overlook a restrictive covenant, and you could be exposed long after the ink dries. This guide walks you through exactly what to check before signing: the clauses that must be present, the red flags that should make you pause, and the points where you genuinely need a qualified solicitor rather than a quick read-through. Settlement agreements are legally binding under the Employment Rights Act 1996 and require the employee to receive independent legal advice before they are enforceable. That cuts both ways — it protects employees, but it also means employers need to get the drafting right from the start. Use this checklist to audit your document before it goes anywhere near a signature.

Review My Settlement Agreement
Instant Access
Lawyer Reviewed

Why this matters

Settlement agreements land on your desk at the worst possible time — usually mid-dispute, under time pressure, with one eye on keeping things quiet. Most UK founders and HR leads scan them quickly, assume the solicitor on the other side has done the heavy lifting, and sign. That is where problems start. Vague confidentiality clauses, missing tax indemnities, poorly scoped waiver language, and unenforceable restrictive covenants are all common. The cost of getting this wrong is not just legal fees — it is reputational risk, tax liability, and the possibility that the agreement does not actually settle what you thought it did.

The Atornee approach

Atornee does not replace the independent legal advice requirement that makes a settlement agreement enforceable — that still needs a qualified solicitor. What it does is get you to that conversation in a much stronger position. Upload your draft settlement agreement and Atornee flags missing clauses, unusual waiver language, tax indemnity gaps, and confidentiality scope issues before you spend time and money on a solicitor review. You arrive knowing what questions to ask and what to push back on. For UK businesses handling multiple settlements or reviewing a draft before sending to the other side, that preparation saves real money and avoids embarrassing oversights.

What you get

A clause-by-clause breakdown of your settlement agreement against standard UK employment law requirements, including waiver scope and tax treatment
Automatic flagging of red flags: vague reference clauses, missing PILON provisions, overbroad confidentiality terms, and unenforceable restrictive covenants
Plain-English explanation of what each section actually means for your business, without the legal padding
A prioritised list of issues to raise with your solicitor, so you use that time efficiently rather than starting from scratch
Identification of clauses that are missing entirely — not just what is wrong with what is there, but what should be there and is not

Before you sign checklist

1
1. Confirm the agreement is in writing and explicitly states it is made under section 203 of the Employment Rights Act 1996 — without this, it is not enforceable as a settlement agreement
2
2. Check the waiver clause lists specific claims by name — a general waiver is not sufficient; it should reference unfair dismissal, discrimination claims, and any other live disputes
3
3. Review the tax indemnity section — confirm who bears liability if HMRC later challenges the tax treatment of any payment above the £30,000 threshold
4
4. Scrutinise the reference clause — vague or absent reference provisions are a common source of post-settlement disputes; the agreed wording should be attached as a schedule
5
5. Check all restrictive covenants for scope, duration, and geographic reach — overly broad restrictions may be unenforceable and could create problems if challenged
6
6. Confirm the confidentiality clause is mutual if that is what was agreed, and that it clearly defines what information is covered and what carve-outs exist
7
7. Verify that the employee has received independent legal advice from a named, qualified adviser — without this, the agreement cannot validly waive statutory employment rights

FAQ

Does a settlement agreement have to be reviewed by a solicitor in the UK?

Yes, for the agreement to be legally enforceable and to validly waive statutory employment rights, the employee must receive independent legal advice from a qualified adviser — typically a solicitor or certified trade union official. This is a hard legal requirement under the Employment Rights Act 1996. Employers do not have the same obligation, but reviewing the document carefully before it is sent is strongly advisable.

What are the most common red flags in a UK employment settlement agreement?

The most common issues are: waiver clauses that are too vague to be enforceable, missing or ambiguous reference provisions, no tax indemnity for payments above the £30,000 tax-free threshold, confidentiality clauses that are one-sided or poorly scoped, and restrictive covenants that are so broad they would not survive a legal challenge. Any of these can undermine the agreement or create liability down the line.

What claims should a settlement agreement waiver cover?

A properly drafted waiver should list specific statutory claims by name — unfair dismissal, wrongful dismissal, discrimination claims under the Equality Act 2010, whistleblowing claims, and any other claims that are live or reasonably foreseeable. A blanket waiver of 'all claims' without specifics is unlikely to be enforceable for statutory rights and should be treated as a red flag.

How much of a settlement payment is tax-free in the UK?

The first £30,000 of a genuine ex gratia termination payment is generally exempt from income tax and National Insurance under current HMRC rules. Payments above that threshold are taxable. Notice pay — whether worked or paid in lieu — is always subject to tax and NI regardless of how it is structured. The settlement agreement should clearly identify how each payment is categorised, and include a tax indemnity clause in case HMRC takes a different view.

Can a settlement agreement be used to settle a discrimination claim?

Yes, but only if the specific discrimination claim is named in the waiver. Discrimination claims under the Equality Act 2010 are statutory rights and cannot be waived by a general clause — they must be explicitly listed. If you are settling a discrimination dispute, make sure the agreement names the protected characteristic and the type of claim being waived.

What happens if a settlement agreement is not drafted correctly?

If the agreement fails to meet the statutory requirements — for example, the employee did not receive independent legal advice, or the waiver does not name specific claims — it will not validly settle those claims. The employee could still bring a tribunal claim even after signing. For employers, a poorly drafted agreement can also create tax exposure or leave restrictive covenants unenforceable. Getting the drafting right before signing is significantly cheaper than litigating afterwards.

Related Atornee Guides

Cheap Contract Solicitor Alternative (UK)

Useful if you want to understand broader options for managing employment contract and settlement document workflows without full solicitor fees at every stage.

Cheap Solicitor for NDA (UK)

Settlement agreements often include confidentiality obligations — pair this guide if you also need a standalone NDA reviewed alongside the settlement.

Atornee Use Cases

See how UK founders and HR leads use Atornee across different document review and employment law scenarios.

External References

GOV.UK Business and Self-employed

Official UK government guidance on employment law obligations, including termination and settlement processes for UK businesses.

UK Legislation

Primary statutory reference for the Employment Rights Act 1996 and Equality Act 2010, which govern the enforceability of settlement agreements and waiver clauses.

ICO Guidance for Organisations

Relevant where settlement agreements include data protection clauses or require handling of personal data as part of the termination process.

Trust & Verification Policy

Authored By

A

Atornee Editorial Team

UK Employment Law Content Research

Reviewed By

C

Compliance Review Desk

UK Business Legal Content QA

Last reviewed on 3/4/2026

"This content is based on analysis of common drafting issues in UK employment settlement agreements and the statutory requirements under the Employment Rights Act 1996. It reflects practical patterns observed across UK business document review workflows, including frequent red flags identified during AI-assisted clause analysis."

References & Sources